Animal Pantry Introduce
Hello, New York pet lovers! For those of us devoted to our animal companions, finding a pet store that truly understands our needs – and more importantly, our pets' needs – is a treasure. We seek a place that offers quality products, competitive prices, and staff who are genuinely knowledgeable and caring. For residents in Farmingdale and the surrounding areas of Long Island, Animal Pantry has established itself as just such a gem. This article aims to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of what makes Animal Pantry a cherished resource for pet owners throughout our vibrant New York community.
In the hustle and bustle of life in New York, our pets are often the calming and joyous constants. Ensuring their health, happiness, and well-being is a top priority, and that journey often begins with reliable access to quality food and supplies. Animal Pantry embodies the essence of a true local pet store – a place where you can find a comprehensive selection of products, benefit from expert advice, and feel like part of a supportive community. As local users, we value businesses that go above and beyond, and Animal Pantry's commitment to great pricing, a clean environment, and outstanding customer service has made it a long-standing favorite for many pet parents on Long Island.
Animal Pantry is conveniently situated at 190 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA. This accessible location in Farmingdale makes it a practical and easy stop for pet owners not only within Farmingdale itself but also from nearby towns and neighborhoods across Nassau and Suffolk Counties on Long Island. Merritts Road provides straightforward access, ensuring a hassle-free trip whether you're making a quick dash for treats or stocking up on a month's worth of food.
For busy New Yorkers, convenience is paramount. The store's placement ensures that it's a central hub for pet supplies, reducing the time and effort required for your shopping trips. Ample parking is typically available directly at the store, making it easy to load larger bags of food or multiple supplies into your vehicle. This ease of access contributes significantly to the stress-free experience that loyal customers have come to expect, solidifying Animal Pantry's role as a convenient and reliable local resource.
Animal Pantry is more than just a retail space; it's a comprehensive hub for pet essentials and community support. Their offerings are tailored to meet the diverse needs of various pets, emphasizing quality and customer satisfaction.
- Wide Selection of Pet Foods: They carry a vast array of pet food brands, including over 45 different dog food brands, offering options for various dietary needs, life stages, and preferences. This includes premium, natural, and specialized formulas.
- Treats and Chews: A diverse assortment of treats for training, dental health, or just rewarding your beloved companions.
- Pet Supplies and Accessories: A comprehensive inventory of essentials for dogs, cats, small animals, and birds, including beds, crates, grooming supplies, supplements, training tools, flea and tick products, bowls, toys, leashes, collars, and apparel.
- Knowledgeable Staff and Management: The team, including named individuals like Andrew and Teresa, is highly praised for being very friendly and informative. They take the time to answer questions and provide valuable advice on pet care and products. As one customer stated, "Andrew & Teresa always take the time to answer all of my questions."
- Special Ordering Services: If a specific item or brand is not currently in stock, the staff are willing to order it for customers, demonstrating their commitment to fulfilling individual needs. "if I need something that they don't have, they order it for me," a customer confirms.
- In-Store Cat Adoption: Animal Pantry hosts Bella Bast Cat Rescue, providing a wonderful opportunity for locals to meet and adopt rescue kittens and cats directly in the store, supporting animal welfare in the community. Dogs are also welcome to visit the store on a leash.
- Low-Cost Veterinary Service: The store facilitates a low-cost veterinary service that visits once a month, offering an accessible option for essential pet healthcare right at a convenient local spot.
- Problem-Solving Expertise: Staff members actively help customers with specific pet challenges, such as behavioral issues. One customer shared, "They have actually helped me solve my cat's marking issues recently."
Animal Pantry distinguishes itself through several key features and highlights that resonate strongly with New York pet owners:
- Exceptional Customer Service: This is perhaps their most celebrated feature. Customers consistently praise the friendliness, helpfulness, and extensive knowledge of the staff and management. Reviews highlight that employees "care about your pet's best interest."
- "Mom and Pop" Feel: Despite offering a wide range of products, the store maintains a welcoming, personal, and community-oriented atmosphere, described by customers as having a "mom n pop feel." This creates a more pleasant and personal shopping experience compared to larger chain stores.
- Clean and Organized Store: The physical environment of the store is consistently described as "immaculate" and "clean," contributing to a comfortable and pleasant shopping experience for both pets and their owners.
- Competitive Pricing: Customers appreciate that Animal Pantry offers "good prices" on their pet food and supplies, providing value without compromising on quality.
- Wide Range of Products, including Hard-to-Find Items: Their extensive inventory ensures that most pet needs are met, and their willingness to order specific items for customers is a huge advantage, especially for those with pets on specialized diets.
- Community Involvement: Hosting Bella Bast Cat Rescue and offering monthly low-cost veterinary services demonstrates their commitment to the broader animal welfare community, providing valuable resources beyond just retail.
- Reliable and Consistent Quality: Long-term customers attest to the consistent quality of service and products over many years, building strong trust within the community.
To connect with Animal Pantry, inquire about specific products, or learn more about their services, you can use the following contact details:
Address: 190 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA
Phone: (516) 586-8665
Mobile Phone: +1 516-586-8665
It is always a good idea to call ahead, especially if you are looking for a very specific item or wish to inquire about the schedule for their low-cost veterinary service or cat adoptions. The friendly staff will be happy to assist you.
For pet owners residing in Farmingdale and across Long Island, Animal Pantry stands out as an exemplary local resource for all their pet's needs. Its convenient location on Merritts Road ensures easy accessibility, making trips for pet supplies efficient and stress-free for busy New Yorkers. However, what truly makes Animal Pantry a cherished and suitable destination for locals is its unique blend of outstanding customer service, a carefully curated selection of high-quality products, and a genuine commitment to the community.
The "mom and pop" atmosphere, coupled with highly knowledgeable and caring staff like Andrew and Teresa, provides a personalized shopping experience that simply cannot be replicated by larger chain stores. The ability to find hard-to-find foods, receive expert advice, and even participate in local cat adoptions or access low-cost veterinary services, demonstrates Animal Pantry's dedication to being a comprehensive and supportive partner in your pet's well-being. For New Yorkers who value quality, convenience, and a truly caring approach to pet care, Animal Pantry is not just a store; it's an indispensable part of our local community.
Animal Pantry Photos









Animal Pantry Location
Animal Pantry
190 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA
Animal Pantry Reviews
I go there all the time to buy my pet food and supplies. The store is clean, the prices are good and the staff is very friendly and very informative. Andrew & Teresa always take the time to answer all of my questions and if I need something that they don't have, they order it for me. Great staff, great store!!!! Love them ❤️
Jun 06, 2025 · Theresa BryantI've been coming here for years to pick up supplies for my cat. The service is always great, where the employees care about your pet's best interest. They have actually helped me solve my cat's marking issues recently. I highly recommend this store to any animal lover and anyone who wants a good and convenient pet store.
Nov 27, 2023 · Kenny ATop Notch customer service. This was my first time here and won’t be the last. They are incredibly knowledgeable and friendly
Nov 21, 2023 · Damon KronowitzBeen going here for a while now and talked to Theresa last week on my neighbor's recommendation. She cared about my dog and didn't try to sell me on anything like other places do. She taught me new things and a better way to feed my dog and told me things to read to help with his hydration and allergies. When people care like her it shows. Definitely a smart girl and beautiful inside and out. Will be back for new stuff soon. Great little store
Nov 11, 2023 · David HGreat place,my go to for all my dogs needs
May 15, 2025 · John S
More Pet Stores Near Me

704 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA

44 Schoolhouse Rd, Old Bethpage, NY 11804, USA

1141 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA

Inside tri county building, 3041 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown, NY 11756, USA

5500 Sunrise Hwy, Massapequa, NY 11758, USA

61 Sunrise Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA

372 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA

127 W Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, USA

750 Montauk Hwy, Copiague, NY 11726, USA

2083 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

85 New Ave, Wyandanch, NY 11798, USA

2435 Grand Ave, Bellmore, NY 11710, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites





