Creepy Creatures

Welcome to Creepy Creatures, a truly unique and captivating pet store nestled in the heart of Farmingdale, New York. If you're a New Yorker with a fascination for the scaly, the slithery, or the strikingly unusual, you've found your ultimate destination. Creepy Creatures isn't your average pet shop; it's a specialized haven dedicated to reptiles, amphibians, invertebrates, and other exotic pets. This store stands out for its incredible selection of creatures, its vibrant and engaging atmosphere, and most importantly, its exceptionally knowledgeable and passionate team who are dedicated to the well-being of every animal and the success of every pet owner.

In a region where finding specialized pet care can sometimes be a challenge, Creepy Creatures fills a vital niche, providing a trusted resource for both seasoned exotic pet enthusiasts and curious newcomers alike. The moment you step inside, you'll be greeted not just by a fascinating array of animals but also by an environment designed to educate and inspire. From meticulously maintained enclosures to thematic decor, every detail is crafted to enhance your experience. Whether you’re looking to add a new member to your family, seeking expert advice on habitat setup, or simply wish to learn more about these incredible animals, Creepy Creatures offers an unparalleled journey into the world of exotic pets right here in New York. Their commitment to responsible pet ownership and ongoing support truly sets them apart as a cornerstone of the local exotic pet community.

Creepy Creatures is conveniently located at 704 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA. Situated on Main Street, the store enjoys a prominent and easily accessible position within the charming and bustling village of Farmingdale, a well-regarded community within Long Island, New York. This central location makes it an ideal destination for residents across Nassau and Suffolk counties, as well as those willing to travel for their specialized offerings.

Farmingdale's Main Street is known for its vibrant local businesses, eateries, and pedestrian-friendly environment, making a visit to Creepy Creatures an easy and enjoyable outing. For those traveling by car, there are often parking options available along Main Street or in nearby municipal lots, ensuring a convenient experience when visiting the store. The strategic placement on a primary thoroughfare means that the store is straightforward to find, whether you're navigating by GPS or simply exploring the area. Its integration into the fabric of Farmingdale Village also means it's often a natural stop for locals running errands or enjoying a day out. For New York residents interested in unique pets, the accessibility of Creepy Creatures makes it a truly valuable and convenient resource for all their exotic animal needs.

Creepy Creatures offers a specialized range of products and services tailored specifically for reptile and exotic pet enthusiasts. Their offerings go beyond simple retail, providing comprehensive support for pet owners.

• Diverse Selection of Reptiles and Exotic Pets: The store specializes in a wide variety of "creepy creatures," including various species of lizards (such as crested geckos, as highlighted by a customer), snakes, amphibians, and possibly invertebrates. This allows customers to find a new, unique family member.
• High-Quality Pet Supplies: They provide all the necessary equipment and supplies for exotic pet care, including specialized enclosures, lighting, heating elements, substrates, decorations, and feeding accessories.
• Live and Frozen Feeder Insects/Rodents: Essential for the diet of many reptiles and amphibians, Creepy Creatures stocks a reliable supply of live feeder insects (crickets, mealworms, etc.) and frozen rodents.
• Bioactive Tank Setup Assistance: As noted in a glowing review, the staff are highly knowledgeable and provide hands-on assistance with setting up bioactive enclosures. This includes guidance on appropriate plants, substrates, and custodians (such as isopods and springtails) to create a self-sustaining environment for the reptiles.
• Expert Advice and Education: The employees are highly knowledgeable about reptile care, husbandry, and behavior. They are "patient and happy to talk and teach," providing valuable information to new and experienced owners alike, ensuring pets thrive. Customers are encouraged to "reach out any time with questions."
• Lizard-Sitting Services: A unique and incredibly convenient service offered is lizard-sitting. This provides peace of mind for reptile owners needing to travel, knowing their pets are in expert, caring hands.
• Kid-Friendly Environment: The staff are exceptionally "patient, kind and fun" with children, actively engaging them in the animal care process and teaching them about the creatures, making it a great educational outing for families.
• Post-Purchase Support: The store emphasizes ongoing support, encouraging customers to contact them with any questions that arise after bringing a pet home, fostering responsible and successful pet ownership.

Creepy Creatures distinguishes itself through several standout features and highlights that contribute to its popularity and reputation among New York's exotic pet community.

• Exceptional Staff Knowledge and Passion: This is arguably their strongest asset, consistently praised by customers. Reviewers highlight staff members like April and Joe, describing them as "the most knowledgeable reptile store I have ever been to." The team's genuine love for reptiles is evident in "how nicely the reptiles are cared for in the store," and their willingness to "teach us all kinds of things."
• Highly Educational Experience: Beyond just selling pets, Creepy Creatures serves as an educational hub. Staff take the time to explain intricate details of care, such as bioactive tank setups, and patiently guide customers through the responsibilities of exotic pet ownership. This makes it an ideal place for both beginners and experienced hobbyists to learn and grow.
• Unique and Engaging Decor: The "decor around the shop is so much fun," creating an immersive and exciting atmosphere for visitors of all ages. This contributes to the overall "10/10 experience" and makes "window shopping" a truly enjoyable activity, as noted by a customer who unexpectedly went home with a new pet.
• Kid-Friendly Environment: The store goes above and beyond to accommodate and engage children. Staff are "super nice and patient" with kids, even letting them "watch and help" with animal feeding. This makes it a fantastic destination for families looking to introduce their children to the wonders of reptiles in a safe and interactive way.
• Reasonable Pricing: Customers appreciate that "The prices are also very reasonable and not expensive compared to other stores." This commitment to fair pricing, combined with high-quality animals and products, offers excellent value to the consumer.
• Specialized Services like Lizard Sitting: The provision of "lizard-sitting services" is a significant highlight, addressing a specific need for reptile owners who require reliable care for their pets while away, showcasing the store's dedication to comprehensive support.
• Healthy and Well-Cared-For Animals: The positive reviews consistently mention the excellent condition of the reptiles in the store, reflecting the staff's dedication to animal welfare and providing healthy pets to customers.

To learn more about Creepy Creatures, inquire about their services, or plan your visit, please use the following contact details:

• Address: 704 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA
• Phone: (516) 586-4080
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-586-4080

For residents across New York, and especially those in the Long Island area, Creepy Creatures in Farmingdale stands out as an indispensable local gem, particularly for anyone with an interest in reptiles and exotic pets. Its suitability for locals is rooted in several key factors that set it apart from general pet stores. Firstly, its highly specialized focus means that New Yorkers seeking specific reptiles, amphibians, or invertebrates, along with their specialized care products, will find an unparalleled selection and expertise that is often lacking elsewhere. This niche focus ensures that pet owners receive accurate, detailed, and species-appropriate advice, which is crucial for the successful keeping of exotic animals.

Secondly, the store’s commitment to education and customer support is exceptional. The staff’s profound knowledge, patience, and willingness to teach are invaluable assets, particularly for new exotic pet owners who might feel overwhelmed by the complexities of setting up a bioactive tank or understanding specific dietary needs. This accessible expertise, coupled with services like lizard-sitting, demonstrates a genuine dedication to fostering responsible pet ownership and providing ongoing assistance, making it a reliable long-term partner for local pet enthusiasts. Finally, the welcoming, kid-friendly atmosphere and fair pricing further solidify its position as a go-to local spot. Creepy Creatures isn't just a store; it’s a community hub for exotic pet lovers, offering both the creatures themselves and the comprehensive support system needed to ensure they thrive right here in New York.

Creepy Creatures

704 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA