Brothers Pets
Pet Health & Care BlogPet Stores Near Me​Vet Near Me
ConnecticutDelawareMarylandMassachusettsNew JerseyNew YorkPennsylvaniaRhode IslandVermont
ConnecticutDelawareMarylandMassachusettsNew JerseyNew YorkPennsylvaniaRhode IslandVermont
Brothers PetsPet Stores Near Me​New YorkKings CountyClinton HillPet Stores ​ in Myrtle AvenueNYC Pet
NYC Pet ico

NYC Pet

464 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

4.0
This pet store is the same price as Amaz*%^n and maybe just a few dollars more but better to support local businesses when a isn’t really a great deal always. Staff was knowledgeable and helpful with a top entry litter box I needed and they had in stock! - Savannah B
NYC Pet Overview Intro Photos Location Reviews

NYC Pet Introduce

For pet parents across New York City, especially those of us living in Brooklyn, the search for quality pet supplies that are both convenient and competitively priced is an ongoing quest. While the ease of online shopping is undeniable, there's a unique value in supporting local businesses that truly understand the needs of our community and our furry, scaled, or feathered family members. This is where NYC Pet on Myrtle Avenue comes into play. Positioned as a modern pet supply store, NYC Pet aims to provide a comprehensive selection of products, from everyday essentials to specialized items, all while maintaining a strong local presence and a commitment to customer service.

NYC Pet recognizes that a great pet store is more than just a place to buy food; it's a resource where you can find knowledgeable staff, get advice, and feel confident that you're making the best choices for your pet's health and happiness. For Brooklynites, having such a resource conveniently located means less time spent searching and more time enjoying life with our pets. They strive to offer competitive pricing, often matching or coming close to large online retailers, making the choice to "support local" an easy and rewarding one. Whether you're stocking up on your usual dog food, seeking a new and innovative toy, or looking for specific health supplies, NYC Pet endeavors to be your go-to neighborhood destination for all things pet-related.


NYC Pet is centrally located at 464 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA. This address places it in the vibrant Fort Greene / Clinton Hill neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it highly accessible for residents across these and surrounding areas. Myrtle Avenue itself is a bustling commercial corridor, ensuring the store is easy to find and integrate into daily errands.

For locals relying on public transportation, the store's location offers excellent connectivity. It's within walking distance of several subway stations, including the G train at Clinton-Washington Avenues, and relatively close to the C train at Lafayette Avenue or Clinton-Washington Avenues. Numerous bus lines also serve the Myrtle Avenue corridor, providing convenient access from various parts of Brooklyn. For those driving, street parking can be found in the neighborhood, though like most of New York City, it can vary in availability. The welcoming storefront on a well-trafficked avenue makes it a visible and convenient stop for pet owners. Its presence in such a lively residential area underscores its role as a key community resource for pet needs.


NYC Pet offers a comprehensive range of products and services designed to meet the diverse needs of pet owners, focusing primarily on dogs and cats, but also stocking items for other small animals.

  • Pet Food: A wide selection of dry, wet, raw, and freeze-dried pet foods from various reputable brands, including specialized diets for different ages, breeds, and health conditions. Brands like Fromm Family Pet Food are carried.
  • Treats: An assortment of treats for training, dental health, or just rewarding your pet, including gourmet and specialty options.
  • Litter and Litter Supplies: Various types of cat litter, litter boxes (including specialized options like top-entry boxes), and accessories to keep feline homes clean.
  • Toys: A broad selection of toys designed for different play styles, sizes, and durability needs for both dogs and cats.
  • Training and Healthcare Products: Items geared towards pet training, as well as general healthcare products like flea & tick prevention, supplements, and grooming tools.
  • Pet Accessories: A variety of accessories including collars, leashes, beds, bowls, crates, and apparel.
  • Online Ordering: Customers can conveniently browse and order products through their website.
  • Local Delivery Service: NYC Pet offers same-day or next-day delivery in Brooklyn and Manhattan for a flat fee, providing a convenient option for busy New Yorkers to receive their pet supplies directly to their home.
  • In-Store Pickup: An option for customers to place orders online and pick them up at the physical store.
  • Knowledgeable Staff: Their team is described as knowledgeable and helpful, ready to assist customers with product selection and advice, whether in-store or by answering questions online.

NYC Pet distinguishes itself through several key features and highlights that cater directly to the needs and preferences of New York City pet owners, particularly those in Brooklyn.

  • Competitive Local Pricing: A significant highlight is their commitment to offering prices comparable to, or just slightly higher than, major online retailers like "Amaz**n." This allows customers to support a local business without feeling penalized on cost, making it a compelling alternative to large e-commerce giants.
  • Knowledgeable and Helpful Staff: Customers consistently praise the staff for being "knowledgeable and helpful." Whether it's guiding a customer to the right product (like a top-entry litter box) or offering general advice, the team provides a personalized and informative shopping experience.
  • Extensive In-Stock Inventory: The ability to find specific items like a "top entry litter box" in stock immediately is a huge convenience for city dwellers who often need items without delay. They pack a "variety into a small store."
  • Focus on Local Business Support: NYC Pet actively encourages and benefits from the local community's desire to support neighborhood businesses. This fosters a sense of community and keeps money circulating within Brooklyn.
  • Convenient Delivery Service: The provision of same-day or next-day delivery across Brooklyn and Manhattan is a major convenience for busy New Yorkers, especially for heavy or bulky pet food bags. This service, when it runs smoothly, is a significant draw.
  • Community Engagement: While not explicitly detailed, their presence on the Myrtle Avenue Brooklyn Partnership website and mentions of local events suggest an engagement with the broader neighborhood community.
  • Accessibility of Storefront: Being located on a main thoroughfare in Fort Greene/Clinton Hill makes the store easily reachable by public transport and for local foot traffic.
  • Online Presence: Their website allows for online ordering and offers resources like tips and advice, catering to the modern consumer's shopping habits.

However, it's also important to note that, as with any business, there can be areas for improvement. A recent review highlighted issues with their delivery service, including failure to notify customers of delays, website information discrepancies, and slow refund processing. This indicates that while the in-store experience is often praised, there may be inconsistencies in their online/delivery operations that potential customers should be aware of.


For inquiries, orders, or to visit the store, you can contact NYC Pet using the following information:

Address: 464 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

Phone: (718) 636-3848

Mobile Phone: +1 718-636-3848

Store Hours (as per various sources, may vary, please confirm):

  • Monday - Friday: 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
  • Saturday: 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM - 6:00 PM

It's always recommended to check their official website or call for the most current hours and delivery policies.


For pet owners living in New York, particularly those in Brooklyn, NYC Pet on Myrtle Avenue presents a highly suitable option for their pet supply needs. In a city where supporting local businesses is increasingly valued, NYC Pet provides a compelling alternative to impersonal online giants by combining competitive pricing with the tangible benefits of a neighborhood store.

What makes NYC Pet particularly appealing to locals is the direct access to knowledgeable and friendly staff who can offer immediate advice and assistance, a stark contrast to the often-anonymous online shopping experience. The ability to walk into a store, find specific items in stock, and receive personalized recommendations creates a sense of community and trust. While their delivery service has faced some challenges, the core in-store experience and their commitment to affordability make them a strong contender for your pet supply dollar.

Ultimately, choosing NYC Pet means investing in a local business that strives to keep pet care accessible and convenient for the busy lives of New Yorkers. It's about more than just transactions; it's about fostering a relationship with a store that cares about your pets as much as you do, right here in our vibrant Brooklyn community.

NYC Pet Photos

NYC Pet Picture 1NYC Pet Picture 2NYC Pet Picture 3NYC Pet Picture 4NYC Pet Picture 5NYC Pet Picture 6NYC Pet Picture 7NYC Pet Picture 8NYC Pet Picture 9NYC Pet Picture 10

NYC Pet Location

NYC Pet

464 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

NYC Pet Reviews

More Pet Stores Near Me​

  • Pet Club BrooklynPet Club Brooklyn4.0 (61 reviews)

    504 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

  • Teacup Puppy Store in New YorkTeacup Puppy Store in New York3.0 (52 reviews)

    39 S Oxford St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

  • Natty Pet ShopNatty Pet Shop3.0 (39 reviews)

    620 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA

  • Whole Pets MarketWhole Pets Market4.0 (255 reviews)

    1216 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

  • Unleashed by PetcoUnleashed by Petco4.0 (686 reviews)

    81 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

  • ALL 4 PETSALL 4 PETS3.0 (33 reviews)

    905 DeKalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11221, USA

  • Doggy NibblesDoggy Nibbles5.0 (1 reviews)

    530 Dean St, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA

  • Magic Kittens CatteryMagic Kittens Cattery4.0 (36 reviews)

    2675 W 36th St, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

  • Anchor Aquarium ServiceAnchor Aquarium Service3.0 (15 reviews)

    Suite 301, 28 Locust St #301, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

  • NYC PetNYC Pet4.0 (111 reviews)

    157 Kent Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

  • City Aquarium LLCCity Aquarium LLC4.0 (4 reviews)

    306 Stagg St, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

  • Aqua Spaces - Aquarium MaintenanceAqua Spaces - Aquarium Maintenance5.0 (32 reviews)

    197 Bush St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Trending Pet Health & Care Blog Posts