Critter Place LLC Introduce
Hello, New Jersey pet parents! Finding a local pet store that not only stocks a wide array of products but also offers genuine expertise and a deep commitment to animal welfare can truly enhance your journey as a pet owner. For those residing in the McAfee area and across the beautiful state of New Jersey, Critter Place LLC stands out as a beloved local establishment. This article will provide you with a clear, engaging, and informative overview of Critter Place LLC, highlighting what makes it a suitable and cherished destination for local users in New Jersey seeking quality pet supplies and thoughtful guidance for their animal companions.
Critter Place LLC is conveniently nestled at 40 New Jersey 94, Col. Plaza, McAfee, NJ 07428, USA. This location places it within the Colonel Plaza, making it easily accessible for residents of McAfee and the wider Sussex County region. Route 94 is a significant thoroughfare, ensuring straightforward navigation for those driving from nearby towns. The presence within a plaza typically means ample parking is available, which is a key convenience, especially when picking up larger bags of food or multiple supplies. This ease of access ensures that pet owners can conveniently visit the store without undue hassle, whether they are making a quick stop for a refill or taking their time to browse for new items for their beloved pets. The local placement ensures it's a quick and practical destination for the community's pet needs.
Critter Place LLC appears to be a comprehensive pet store, offering a range of products and likely some services designed to cater to various pet needs. While the precise details of every service are best confirmed directly with the store, based on the customer reviews and the nature of similar local pet establishments, we can infer a broad scope of offerings.
- Wide Range of Pet Supplies: As a dedicated pet store, Critter Place LLC undoubtedly stocks an extensive selection of supplies for various types of pets. This would include essential items such as leashes, collars, beds, crates, carriers, and a diverse assortment of toys for enrichment and play.
- Premium Pet Food and Nutrition: A significant focus for many pet stores is high-quality food. Critter Place LLC likely offers a variety of premium dog and cat food brands, including dry kibble, wet food, and potentially specialized diets. Their affiliation with brands like Fromm Family Pet Food (as suggested by a search result) indicates a commitment to quality nutrition. They may also carry food for small animals, birds, and fish.
- Live Animals (Carefully Vetted): One review specifically mentions purchasing a husky from the store two years prior, indicating that Critter Place LLC engages in the responsible sale of live animals, particularly puppies. The review highlights the owner's thorough vetting process for potential owners, suggesting a strong commitment to finding proper homes. This likely extends to other animals they may sell, such as small animals, birds, or fish, along with all the necessary habitats and accessories.
- Pet Grooming Supplies: While not explicitly stated as a service, a comprehensive pet store typically offers a range of grooming tools and products, including shampoos, conditioners, brushes, nail clippers, and dental care items.
- Expert Advice and Consultations: A key "service" highlighted by customers is the knowledgeable staff and owner who provide valuable advice. This informal consultation helps pet owners make informed decisions about nutrition, training, and overall pet care.
- Specialty Items: Given their knowledgeable approach, they may also stock specialty items like feeders, live insects (crickets, worms) for reptiles or birds, and other unique products that cater to diverse pet populations.
The positive customer feedback for Critter Place LLC highlights several distinct features that make it a standout choice for local pet owners in New Jersey.
- Highly Knowledgeable and Helpful Staff/Owner: This is arguably the strongest highlight. Both customer reviews enthusiastically praise the woman "that's always there, I'm assuming the owner," describing her as "amazing and always extremely helpful and knowledgeable." This level of expertise ensures that customers receive accurate advice and find the right products for their specific pet needs.
- Genuine Care for Animals: The owner's dedication to the welfare of the animals is profoundly evident. The review about the husky purchase explicitly states, "The owner... cares greatly about the animals. She made sure my dog had a proper home and made sure I knew 100 percent what to expect by owning a husky before allowing me to purchase him." This commitment to responsible pet placement is a significant differentiating factor and instills trust in customers.
- Personalized Attention: The individualized attention given to ensuring a proper home for a specific breed like a husky suggests a personalized approach to customer service, moving beyond a transactional interaction to a more supportive and advisory role.
- Comprehensive Product Range: While not detailed in the reviews, the nature of a "pet store for all your pet needs" implies a broad inventory, reducing the need for customers to visit multiple locations for different types of supplies.
- Local, Community-Oriented Feel: The consistent presence of the knowledgeable owner contributes to a strong local, community-focused atmosphere, where customers feel valued and receive tailored support. This fosters loyalty and trust.
- Commitment to Education: By ensuring prospective owners "knew 100 percent what to expect," Critter Place LLC demonstrates a valuable commitment to educating clients, promoting responsible pet ownership from the outset.
For inquiries, product availability, or to simply chat with the knowledgeable team at Critter Place LLC, here is their contact information:
Address: 40 New Jersey 94, Col. Plaza, McAfee, NJ 07428, USA
Phone: (973) 209-4461
Mobile Phone: +1 973-209-4461
In conclusion, for pet owners throughout New Jersey, particularly in the McAfee area, Critter Place LLC emerges as an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended local pet store. Its foundation rests on the remarkable knowledge and genuine care exhibited by its staff, notably the assumed owner, who goes above and beyond to ensure both the happiness of pets and the preparedness of their human companions. The ability to cater to "all your pet needs," combined with a deeply responsible approach to animal welfare, creates an environment where customers feel confident and supported in their choices. This dedication to personalized service, comprehensive offerings, and a strong commitment to the animals they serve makes Critter Place LLC not just a place to buy pet supplies, but a trusted partner in responsible pet ownership for the New Jersey community.
Critter Place LLC Photos










Critter Place LLC Location
Critter Place LLC
40 New Jersey 94, Col. Plaza, McAfee, NJ 07428, USA
Critter Place LLC Reviews
Such a great place for all your pet needs. The woman thats always there, im assuming the owner, i amazing and always extremely helpful and knowledgeable
May 08, 2025 · Andrew ChletsosI bought my husky here two years ago. The owner was very knowledgeable and cares greatly about the animals. She made sure my dog had a proper home and made sure I knew 100 percent what to expect by owning a husky before allowing me to purchase him.
Jun 19, 2018 · Jenna FitzBarbara is awesome. So friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. I bought two young parakeets and she took the time to set them up and help me with all of their needs. I will be back!!
Oct 07, 2021 · Keri MI love this place..always very nice..I would rather support small businesses...the owner and staff are so wonderful.The prices for toys, treats and other supplies are beyond reasonable. I go no where else.
May 02, 2025 · Jennifer DelongisBarbara was cheerful and knowledgeable while dealing with one customer at a time. We bought our puppy from her and she is an absolute doll. “Aunt” Barb knew a lot about her habits and personality, which is extremely useful in her training. Her employees are very friendly, and the small store is kept clean. I was very happy to have our puppy’s lineage and appreciate that she’s been chipped. Barb packed up a goodie bag for us and let us know about the puppy’s favorite toys. We normally purchase our dogs from a breeder, but are thrilled with The Critter Place. 😀
Mar 26, 2020 · Lisa VerHage
More Pet Stores Near Me

205 NJ-23, Wantage, NJ 07461, USA

39 NJ-15, Lafayette Township, NJ 07848, USA

85 Marshall Hill Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480, USA

31 Sparta Ave, Sparta, NJ 07871, USA

29 Main St, Warwick, NY 10990, USA

124 Jersey Ave, Port Jervis, NY 12771, USA

124 Jersey Ave, Port Jervis, NY 12771, USA

1483 NJ-23 #14b, Kinnelon, NJ 07405, USA

63 Main St, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403, USA

55 Main St, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403, USA

8 Van Dam Ave, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403, USA

549 NY-17 Suite C, Tuxedo Park, NY 10987, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites





