First Choice Aquatics Introduce
Introduction / Overview
For aquatic enthusiasts and aspiring fish keepers across New Jersey, finding a dedicated and knowledgeable pet store focused on the intricate world of aquariums can make all the difference in the success and enjoyment of their hobby. First Choice Aquatics, located in Flemington, NJ, is precisely that kind of establishment. This isn't just a place to buy fish; it's a specialized hub for everything related to aquatic life, from vibrant saltwater setups to serene freshwater tanks. What truly sets First Choice Aquatics apart, according to local patrons, is their deep expertise, comprehensive selection, and an unwavering commitment to customer support. They provide not only a fantastic array of aquatic supplies and healthy fish but also invaluable guidance and maintenance programs designed to ensure your aquarium thrives. Whether you're a seasoned aquarist looking to stabilize a long-standing tank or a newcomer eager to set up your first aquatic ecosystem, First Choice Aquatics offers a welcoming and informative environment where passion for the underwater world comes to life.
Location and Accessibility
First Choice Aquatics is conveniently situated at 257 US-202 31 S, Flemington, NJ 08822, USA. This prime location on the conjunction of US-202 and US-31 South makes it exceptionally accessible for residents throughout Hunterdon County and the wider central New Jersey region. Both US-202 and US-31 are major roadways, ensuring a straightforward drive whether you're coming from neighboring towns like Ringoes, Branchburg, or even from further afield. The ease of access is a significant advantage for pet owners, especially when transporting live fish or larger aquarium supplies. With its clear address and placement within a commercial area, finding First Choice Aquatics is a hassle-free experience. This strategic location solidifies its role as a central and dependable resource for aquatic enthusiasts across New Jersey, making it a convenient destination for all your fishkeeping needs.
Services Offered
- Aquarium Maintenance Programs: First Choice Aquatics offers professional maintenance services for both freshwater and saltwater aquariums. These programs are designed to keep tanks stable, healthy, and visually appealing, handling tasks like water changes, water parameter testing, and equipment checks.
- Expert Consultation and Advice: The staff, including experienced individuals like Randy and Justin, provide invaluable expertise on all aspects of aquarium keeping. This includes guidance on setting up new tanks, selecting appropriate fish and corals, managing water chemistry, and troubleshooting common issues.
- Vast Selection of Aquatic Supplies: The store boasts a "fantastic selection" of supplies essential for maintaining aquariums. This likely includes filtration systems, lighting, heaters, pumps, substrate, decor, water conditioners, and testing kits.
- Healthy Fish and Livestock Sales: Customers can find a diverse array of healthy fish for both freshwater and saltwater setups. The emphasis is on quality and vitality, ensuring that new additions thrive in home aquariums.
- Coral Additions and Care: For saltwater enthusiasts, First Choice Aquatics provides expertise and potentially a selection of corals, helping to enhance the beauty and complexity of reef tanks.
- Troubleshooting and Problem Solving: Given their deep knowledge, the staff is well-equipped to help customers diagnose and resolve common aquarium problems, from algae outbreaks to fish health issues.
- Customer Education: Through patient explanations and helpful tips, the team educates customers on best practices for aquarium maintenance and livestock care, empowering them to become more successful aquarists.
Features / Highlights
- Exceptional Expertise and Knowledgeable Staff: Customers consistently praise the deep knowledge of the staff, singling out individuals like Randy for his "expertise" and Justin for being "incredibly patient" and providing "great tips." This expertise is crucial for the complex hobby of aquarium keeping.
- Comprehensive Aquarium Maintenance Program: For those struggling with tank stability or fish loss, their maintenance program is a significant highlight, leading to "much more stable, beautiful and fun to watch" tanks, as one long-time aquarist experienced.
- Fantastic Selection of Aquatic Supplies and Fish: The store is noted for its wide variety of products and healthy livestock, making it a one-stop shop for both new and experienced aquarists.
- Outstanding Customer Service: Reviewers emphasize the staff's willingness to "go above and beyond," demonstrating patience, thoroughly answering questions, and providing an "exceptional" customer experience. This personal touch fosters loyalty.
- Passion for Aquatics: It's evident that the staff, particularly Justin, is "passionate about what he does," which translates into enthusiastic and dedicated service, making the experience more engaging for customers.
- Long-Term Tank Stability: For those with established tanks, their programs and advice contribute to greater stability and reduced issues like fish loss, turning a potentially frustrating hobby into a rewarding one.
- Community Trust: The store has clearly built a reputation for reliability and quality, with customers expressing "gratitude" and "highly recommending" the establishment.
Contact Information
Address: 257 US-202 31 S, Flemington, NJ 08822, USA
Phone: (908) 751-5663
Mobile Phone: +1 908-751-5663
For inquiries about products, services, or to schedule a maintenance consultation, New Jersey residents are encouraged to call First Choice Aquatics during their business hours. It is always a good idea to confirm stock availability for specific fish or supplies before visiting.
Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals
For aquarium enthusiasts and prospective fish keepers across New Jersey, First Choice Aquatics in Flemington stands out as an exceptionally suitable and valuable local resource. Its primary appeal for locals stems from its specialized focus and profound expertise in the aquatic realm. Unlike general pet stores, First Choice Aquatics offers a deep well of knowledge, exemplified by staff members like Randy and Justin, whose patience and willingness to provide "great tips" are consistently praised. This expert guidance is invaluable, whether you're a beginner setting up your first tank or a veteran struggling with long-term stability, as demonstrated by the customer who transformed their 30-year-old tank with their maintenance program. Furthermore, the "fantastic selection" of healthy fish and comprehensive supplies means that locals have a reliable, high-quality source for all their aquatic needs right in their backyard, saving them from the often frustrating experiences at less specialized big-box stores. Its convenient location on major routes 202 and 31 ensures easy access from across central New Jersey. In essence, First Choice Aquatics is more than just a pet store; it's a community hub where passion meets professionalism, providing New Jersey residents with the knowledge, products, and support necessary to create and maintain thriving, beautiful aquatic environments for years to come.
First Choice Aquatics Photos










First Choice Aquatics Location
First Choice Aquatics
257 US-202 31 S, Flemington, NJ 08822, USA
First Choice Aquatics Reviews
We are so grateful to Randy at First Choice Aquatics for all his expertise with our 55 G salt water aquarium. We have had a tank for over 30 years. Water changes were a pain and we seem to lose a lot of fish. But now with Randy's maintenance program and coral additons, our tank is so much more stable, beautiful and fun to watch.
Dec 05, 2024 · Bob HaakeFirst Choice Aquatics is an excellent store with a fantastic selection of aquatic supplies and fish. The staff is knowledgeable and always willing to help. I want to give a special shout-out to Justin, who went above and beyond to assist me during my visit. He was incredibly patient, answered all my questions, and even provided some great tips on maintaining my aquarium. It's clear that Justin is passionate about what he does, and his dedication to customer service really made my experience exceptional. Highly recommend this store!
Jan 30, 2025 · Vincent BaroneWe drove an hour to go to Sea Level Aquarium just to see what’s up! We’re in morris county so not too many LFS around here for reefers. This shop is awesome!! I understand it’s new and he’s just stocking so I can’t wait to come back. This store and tanks are CLEAN!! I love to see a clean aquarium store!! The collection although small was NICE!! we came away with 5 frags and some snails. Great prices and the owner (I didn’t catch your name!!) is really knowledgeable with the coral he sells. Super impressed!! You absolutely should know what you sell, trade, and deal with. I’m excited to come back and see what else you have!! My wife REALLY wants one of those bright orange mushrooms so when it spawns we’ll be there!!
Jan 28, 2024 · Merissa “OneMerissa” MackinWe have had Randy from First Choice Aquatics do a spring clean up of our pond for the past few years and can't say enough good things about him. He is professional and friendly, lets us know when to expect him, shows up on time, and works hard to get the job done. Randy is knowledgeable about ponds and everything involved with maintaining one and can even design and install new ones. We are thrilled with our crystal clear pond and he was finished in a few hours, always making sure our yard is left the way he found it. Thanks Randy
May 23, 2023 · Denise ParkanyiI had Randy at First Choice move my aquarium after we moved to the area. Long story short, while I was away on vacation prior to the move, my set up lost power and I lost everything in my reef. I had to drain the water and start all over. I basically wanted to throw it all out, but figured I’d give it one last try. Randy did a complete rehaul, and cleanup of my system to got me up and running. The pictures speak for themselves (before and after). I will update once the water clears and the the tank is restocked. They were very clean, professional and the customer service was exceptional. I highly recommend.
Jan 10, 2022 · Eduardo Montes
More Pet Stores Near Me

531 US-22 E, White House Station, NJ 08889, USA

1802 State Route 31, Grayrock Rd, Clinton, NJ 08809, USA

300 US-202 #6, Raritan, NJ 08869, USA

Wismer Rd, Doylestown, PA 18902, USA

36 Hill and Dale Rd, Lebanon, NJ 08833, USA

93 W Main St, Somerville, NJ 08876, USA

3495 Brunswick Pike U.S. 1, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA

6637 Easton Rd, Pipersville, PA 18947, USA

6370 Easton Rd, Pipersville, PA 18947, USA

6026 Easton Rd, Pipersville, PA 18947, USA

33 Pershing Ave, Ewing Township, NJ 08618, USA

111 Lawrenceville Rd, Lawrenceville, NJ 08648, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites





